
Title: A River Runs Through it
Genre: Drama, Autobiographical
MPAA Rating: PG
Year: 1992
Director: Robert Redford
Top Billed Cast: Craig Sheffer, Brad Pitt, Tom Skerritt
Brief Synopsis: Two brothers grow up taught by their father, a Presbyterian minister. The setting is Montana where fly fishing is just as important as religion. The boys launch adult lives and the film follows them.
My Word to the Wise: When a loved one gets into trouble a little too often, “we can still love completely without complete understanding.” This is just one life lesson we learn from this truly remarkable film. It’s based on the autobiography of college professor/writer/poet Norman MacLean.
The rest of this review may contain spoilers.
Norman and Paul MacLean steal a boat in high school. They nearly kill themselves in the white water. If you were a young man or have known a young man, you know stunts like this often happen on the way to adulthood. Two brothers, sons of the town preacher, two directions. Craig Sheffer, Brad Pitt, and Tom Skerritt are excellent actors who are used by director Robert Redford to paint the canvas of Norman’s life. We learn that fly fishing is more poetry than an aisle a sporting goods store. We learn that writing and applying to college is a rite of passage that can open ones eyes as much as knock one to the ground.
This is not an open-ended movie, things happen and stop and consequences come both bad and good. It’s a film about the spirit of these two young men and what makes them great individuals, despite tragedy. This film is an emotional journey and you don’t just see Montana, you are transported there. For many years now I have called this my favorite movie. It is full of cinematic Americana and collected stories of a gifted author’s life growing up in Missoula, Montana.




“Infinitely Polar Bear” is movie from the perspective of a daughter growing up with a bipolar dad who we are expected to see as responsible. I disagree with what the poster and the marketing infer. He only perpetuates the stigma of bipolars being irresponsible, loud, and dangerous. Maya Forbes both directed it and wrote the screenplay. She is best known for being on the writing team on the animated feature “Monsters vs. Aliens” and “Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Dog Days.” This is her directorial debut.
I felt the screenplay failed to portray the medical and therapeutic necessities for a bipolar. I think it would have been a lot stronger if Cam and his family went to therapy and learned more about the disorder that is well known to cause erratic behavior, depression, suicide, and an inability to work. In turn, this would educate the largely ignorant audience. There are many functional professionals and
The idea that he can control it without lithium is just selfish. Bipolar has been described as a broken mood thermostat, even at 115 degrees fahrenheit, your brain can’t cool down. The same is true for the depressive or “cold” phase when your mood plummets. He puts his daughters in grave danger several times in the movie. In real life, they would be taken by social services. I did like the acting and if you’re a Mark Ruffalo fan, you’ll enjoy seeing him in a very obnoxious, tortured role. He usually doesn’t play roles like that this well. Too bad he didn’t have a better script. For irresponsibly furthering a negative stereotype of a psychiatric disorder through a negligent script, it lost two points with me. As cute as the title is, I’ll have to keep waiting for the movie that shows a functional bipolar. Maybe I’ll have to write it.

You must be logged in to post a comment.